December 9, 2018 · How to Up Cycle Old Christmas Cards into Present Tags! Christmas Start by gathering your materials. I used:-Old Christmas Cards-Plain Present Tags-Scissors-Glue Stick-Twine Using the plain tags, find a card with a design that you like and will fit! Cut out your design. Add glue to your cut out design. Press the design firmly to the plain tag. You can write who it’s “To:” and “From:” on the back! Add it to your present and enjoy!